All poems

The Blood Between Us · Ep 05/09 · Performance vs. Truth

The Ones Who Pretend to Love You in Public

There's a special kind of cruelty in being loved only where others can see.

Makena Brandon · 3 min read

Cover for The Ones Who Pretend to Love You in Public

There's a special kind of cruelty in being loved only where others can see. The camera flashes, the laughter echoes — and for a moment, I almost believe it's real. You wrap your arm around me like a ribbon tied on a wound

you don't want anyone to notice. You smile, and the world claps for our perfection. They call us close, tight-knit, 'a beautiful family.' I want to scream.

If only they knew how cold love feels when the lights go off. How fast warmth evaporates when the audience leaves. How your voice changes — from honey to blade — the second the door clicks shut.

You perform affection the way some people rehearse lies — flawlessly, repeatedly, until even you forget the truth. And I play my role too, the grateful child, the proud partner, the loyal friend. Because breaking character means breaking peace.

They call you generous. I've seen your kindness measured in witnesses. You only give when someone's watching. You only apologize when someone's judging.

And every public hug feels like a staged confession to crimes no one else can see. There's an art to pretending — you've mastered it. Smiles like camouflage, charity like redemption.

And me? I became your proof of goodness. Your prop. Your living alibi. Behind closed doors, you turn the volume of your love down to a whisper sharp enough to cut.

I bleed silently, so the world can keep believing your version. You say, 'don't make a scene.' But my pain is already a theater — you just refuse to buy a ticket.

You know what hurts the most? Not the cruelty — but the disbelief. When I finally spoke, they said, 'but you always look so happy together.'

And just like that, my truth drowned in your reputation. You keep your halo spotless. You know which words to say, which charities to mention, which smiles to fake. You've built an empire on pretending to care.

And I — I built silence around your secret. There are photos of us in other people's homes. Framed memories, frozen lies. Every time I see them, I wonder how many people

are trapped inside pictures of a happiness that never existed. Sometimes I envy the strangers who only know your good side. They get to love you without consequences. They get to believe you are kind.

But I know the truth: You don't love people — you love applause. And the day no one's watching, you'll forget how to care.

I've stopped trying to make you see me. You only see reflections that praise you. And I refuse to shine just to keep your mask lit. So when the curtain falls, and the lights fade,

and your admirers go home, you'll stand alone — in the dark you created. No cameras, no audience, just echoes of the names you used to polish your image.

And maybe then, you'll understand what love truly was — the quiet loyalty you mistook for weakness, the real I gave you when all you wanted was show. The world may never know what it cost me to smile beside you.

But I do. And that's enough. Because truth — even silent — is stronger than performance. And I will never play your part again.

— Makena Brandon · Discussion Newspaper Network Publishers